Language
Writing an arguable thesis that answers the strongest objection

Listen
An arguable thesis is a claim that an informed, reasonable person could dispute; a fact or a topic is not a thesis. A strong thesis names the best objection, concedes what is true in it, and then shows why the claim still holds. Steelmanning means answering the strongest fair version of the other side, while a straw man attacks a weak version that nobody actually holds.
What you will learn
- Tell an arguable thesis apart from a fact or a topic
- Identify the strongest fair objection to a claim and distinguish steelmanning from a straw man
- Write a thesis that concedes a real strength of the opposing view before stating a contestable claim
A thesis is the one claim your whole essay sets out to prove. To be worth proving, it has to be ARGUABLE: an informed, reasonable person could disagree and point to real evidence for the other side.
TEST 1: FACT OR CLAIM? 'Shakespeare wrote plays' is a fact; no one disputes it, so there is nothing to argue. 'Shakespeare's comedies depend more on timing than on surprising plots' is arguable, because a careful reader could defend the opposite. A topic, such as 'social media and teenagers', is not a thesis either, because it takes no position.
TEST 2: CAN YOU NAME THE BEST OBJECTION? Imagine the most capable person who disagrees with you. What would they say? Choosing the strongest fair version of their view is called STEELMANNING. Its opposite is the STRAW MAN, where a writer knocks down a weak version that nobody actually holds. Readers who disagree with you are not persuaded by a straw man, because it is not their real view.
HOW TO ANSWER IT. A strong thesis often does two jobs in one sentence. The first part CONCEDES what is true in the objection, often starting with 'Although' or 'While'. The second part makes your claim. Your body paragraphs then give the REFUTATION: not denying the conceded point, but showing why it matters less than the reasons for your claim, or why it does not apply here.
WORKED EXAMPLE. Start: 'Many schools assign homework.' Step 1, diagnose: it is a fact, so it cannot anchor an argument. Step 2, take a position: high schools should limit homework to about an hour a night. Step 3, find the best objection: practice at home helps students master skills such as math and languages. Step 4, join concession and claim: 'Although practice at home builds skills, high schools should cap homework at about an hour a night, because beyond that point extra assignments cut into sleep and leave less time to practice anything well.'
STOP AND TRY. Turn 'Many people own smartphones' into an arguable thesis, then write the strongest objection someone could raise against it.
Key words
- arguable thesis
- A claim that an informed, reasonable person could dispute with real evidence.
- steelman
- The strongest fair version of the opposing view, which you state before you answer it.
- straw man
- A weak or distorted version of the opposing view that a writer attacks instead of the real one.
- concession
- Admitting what is true or reasonable in the opposing view.
- refutation
- Explaining why the conceded point does not overturn your claim.
Check yourself
Think about it
Which of your own beliefs would survive an honest concession to its strongest objection?